How Can Firms Effectively Use Technology in Customer Journey Management

the results of a literature review to identify how IT and digital


Introduction
As societies and markets are being continually transformed by digital technologies, the workaround where the customer is found has become complex, going through multiple ordering channels, interactions, advertisements, and influences, with a mixture of both physical and digital touchpoints. Under this reality, organizations rely on a digital transformation to enable customer-centricity and improve customer experience (Columbus, 2020). A recent study estimated that 55 of organizations with high digital maturity focus on digital transformation to create a unified customer experience (Gurumurthy et al., 2020).
The restrictions imposed by the Covid-19 pandemic have impacted the Consumer Journey (CJ), pushing organizations to quickly adapt by embedding digital-led experiences to overcome limitations on even simple activities, such as going out to a grocery store or dining in a restaurant (Diebner et al., 2020). Organizations need a Total Experience (TX) strategy to continuously enhance their Customer Experience (CX) and Employee Experience (EX), especially while these interactions become more digital, mobile, and distributed (Wong et al., 2021). CJ mapping is the first step toward improving the TX by identifying how their CX currently looks and where it can be improved.
A global Gartner research assessing companies that have mapped their CJ revealed that for 54 of them, their artifacts became wall art, as they failed to create digital services and IT developments that improved customer experience (Chiu & Daigler, 2019a). Moreover, firms expect from technology a 360º view of the purchase stages in order to identify which stage of the journey each customer is on, with all the many variables involved, thereby creating abstract and unrealistic expectations (Davis et al., 2019).
Academic and business literature has explored CJ and CX topics through a myriad of use cases within marketing and service research perspectives. A recent study around methodology used on 143 CX research papers revealed that they rely on surveys (31.15 ) and conceptual models (20.28 ), with very few practical implications (De Keyser et al., 2020). Although a vast majority of CJ research cites technology broadly (as in Hamilton et al., 2020;Nam & Kannan, 2020) or specifically (as in Graves et al., 2019;McColl-Kennedy et al., 2019;Campbell et al., 2020), the literature still lacks a practical information systems approach that could handle the emerging CJ challenges currently amplified by Covid-19.
The present research study summarizes the results of a literature review to identify how IT and digital assets can be effectively used in CJ efforts by organizations. It extracts valuable insights from 33 unique CJ-focussed articles that directly cite technology, the context used, the enabler technologies, and their role on CJ management. The summary of insights will be relevant Customer Journey (CJ) mapping offers a view of the Customer Experience (CX) from a customer's standpoint, which acts as the first step towards a myriad of actions that can be performed to improve CX. While CJ mapping has proven to be helpful in a wide range of use cases, companies still struggle to apply technology to make it effective. This research performs a literature review to identify how IT and digital assets can be used in the CJ context, providing practical examples for organizations willing to implement a consumer-centered IT strategy. As a result, it was found that IT can be used in three primary contexts for CJ: mapping, enabling, and monitoring. 34 to organizations engaged in customer-centric digital transformation by helping them to develop a clear view on the drivers for technology usage in CJ.
In the next section, we discuss the interface between the CJ and technology, including open questions relevant to the theme. The focus is on three main themes identified in the literature review: how technology can map, enable, and monitor the journey. In discussing the results, we determine which technologies are related to each use case and provide practical examples, contributing to the formulation of a digital strategy that focuses on the development of CX capabilities.

Summary ofinsights from the literature review
The CJ term emerged from customer experience research as a way to represent a set of steps the customer needs to take towards product or service consumption (Tax et al., 2013). Those steps are referred to as "touchpoints" in most related literature and include which actions, feelings, and connections the customer goes through regarding pre-consumption, consumption, and post-consumption (Lemon & Verhoef, 2016). Information systems literature was the first to adopt the term in early 2011 (Teixeira et al., 2011), followed by a wide range of use case studies among business and marketing research.
The derivative term "consumer journey" (CJ) is used in the same context as the "customer journey". However, the term "consumer" is more likely to be used in a retail scope, while "customer" is used for a broader range of services and B2B relationships.

Customer Journey Touchpoints
The main activity of CJ mapping is to identify a timeline view of all customer experience events during the purchase process (Rosenbaum et al., 2017). The literature refers to touchpoints as events on the CJ timeline, including moments the customer interacts with a company, as well as their actions, decisions, and feelings.
Touchpoints are organized in three customer experience stages: pre-purchase, purchase, and post-purchase. The pre-purchase stage begins from recognizing a necessity, searching for a solution, and considering buying (De Keyser et al., 2020). Purchase touchpoints include customer interactions with a company during the purchase event, such as choosing the product, purchasing and paying for it, and considering the overall environmental conditions, both physical and digital. The post-purchase stage includes customer interaction with the product, service, or company after the order itself. It includes behaviours such as usage, brand engagement, and after-sales services (Lemon & Verhoef, 2016). Previous consumption experiences generate a general background for the consumer before starting the CJ, which also influences future experiences.

Customer Journey Use Cases
CJ mapping is revealed to be a powerful resource for a wide range of business perspectives. The CX may differ significantly across global markets, even within the same niche. Through CJ analysis, organizations can adapt their regional go-to-market strategy, identifying local cultural aspects, the level of technology adoption, local regulations, and competitors, among others (Nam & Kannan, 2020).
Customer decisions throughout the CJ may be influenced directly or indirectly by others, known as "traveling companions" (Hamilton et al., 2020). Individually or aggregated, traveling companions affect several stages of the CJ, including driving motivation, offering information, and evaluating the decision process. Simultaneously, traveling companions are also influenced during the CJ according to customer feedback and experience. To have a correct understanding of the influence that travelling companions may have during the CJ is key to an organization's CX design.
As technology adoption to drive marketing strategies intensifies, the amount of data marketing professionals must deal with might become overwhelming. CJ mapping is identifed as an effective tool to teach datadriven marketing discipline, providing a link between theory and practice around CX (Micheaux & Bosio, 2019).

Customer Journey and IS Alignment
The term "customer journey" was first used in the scientific literature when Teixeira and colleagues (2011) presented a design model for service systems within a human-computer research scope. While not attributing a definition for CJ, their research gave a relevant foundation for the topic, introducing what they called Customer Experience Modeling as a new way to represent and evaluate customer experiences through a systematized view to guide service design and developments.

William Boscardini Helouani
From a more recent standpoint, De Keyser and colleagues (2020) also pointed out relevant research questions around information systems and CJ while reviewing 143 publications about CX. Although some of the previous questions remain unanswered, some of the more complex ones were raised. A comprehensive list of information systems-related questions around CJ can be found in Table 1, summarizing the main business research concerns.

Methodology
The current research performs a systematic literature review to identify multiple expectations from adopting IT assets and capabilities in CJ management from a business perspective. To create a replicable and transparent process in the literature analysis, we used a framework proposed by Ali and Usman (2018).
First, we sourced articles within the Web of Science research index platform, applying the filters "Customer Journey OR Consumer Journey." We filtered the 235 results to articles published in journals, excluding books and conference materials, which resulted in a total of 144 different pieces. Then, we used technology-related keywords to refine the search results and identify relevant articles for this research. The complete list of search terms and identified articles is displayed in Table  2.
After removing duplicate results that represented articles citing more than one keyword, the total number of evaluated research articles was reduced to 47. Finally, the context in which such technologies are mentioned was extracted and grouped according to qualitative similarities, summarizing the primary application purpose. During the qualitative analysis, 14 articles were identified that mentioned technology outside of the CJ context, which were thus excluded from further consideration. This additional reduction resulted in 33 articles that served as the foundation for this research.

Key Findings and Discussion
The research found three main drivers for technology adoption in the CJ context: mapping, enabling, and monitoring the journey. First, it was pointed out by 7 of the 33 evaluated articles that technology is fundamental in mapping the journey itself, from which the current experience and different persona CJs emerge. Once the mapping is done, the technology enables the journey through digital assets that serve as touchpoints, giving The first attribution of a CJ definition, as provided by Kankainen and colleagues (2012), referred to CJ as "one of the concepts applied in service design to emphasize and define the process". To support the definition, they also highlight the CJ objective to use a client's perspective to identify and describe different touchpoints in the CX.
CJ was put at the center of the "service delivery network" concept in the human-computer field, which explains how two or more companies can offer services together while presenting themselves through a single brand from a customer perspective (Tax et al., 2013). In addition to a solid foundation for the CJ, Tax and colleagues (2013) contributed a wide range of future research questions on the topic related to various business perspectives, such as strategic capabilities, customer co-creation, C2C interactions, customer relationships management, and service success.
CJ mapping is appropriate for designing user interfaces and a valuable tool for firms looking for CX improvements. Introducing CJ as a marketing discipline, Lemon and Verhoef (2016) highlighted its relevance as omnichannel became the new standard, where customers rely on several touchpoints in their consumption process. The higher the number of touchpoints a CJ may have, the less control over the experience the firm possesses.
Along with an overview of marketing theory related to consumer experience, Lemon and Verhoef (2016) created a research agenda for the CJ topic, suggesting its analysis through several prisms: drivers for customer experience, CJ mapping, multidevice and mobile journey, customer experience measurement, experience design, and from an internal organization perspective. Among the 35 proposed research questions, eight directly involves the information systems field. While the questions remain unanswered, they nevertheless offer a significant contribution to this research.
Information technology also constitutes a key to digitalizing service-only journeys through connecting and enabling new service encounters. A "service encounter" is a touchpoint in the CJ that includes a service experience perspective (Voorhees et al., 2017). The stages of a CJ may be classified as pre-core, core, and post-core service encounters when viewed from a service prism. Voorhees and colleagues (2017) Table 3 shows the key outcomes from the literature review.

Customer Journey Mapping
The first step in improving CX throughout the CJ is to perform a touchpoints mapping. This mapping is often performed manually through cardboards during a physical workshop with around 12 people from different company areas (Chiu & Daigler, 2019b). Still, it only gives a static vision of the journey that might become quickly obsolete. Following the CJ approach's popularization, several specialized mapping software options emerged, customers physical access to specific touchpoints, helping customers advance in their journey, and personalizing the experience. "Enabling" is the most used context where technology relates to CJ, appearing in 29 articles. Finally, technology can also monitor the whole CJ, both from a specific customer point of view and with a broader perspective on CX performance, as stated in 14 articles. The monitoring phase proved to be crucial to generate improvements on the journey, and once any touchpoint is changed, the map must also be updated.
From each analyzed article, we extracted the specific context in which IT can be applied to CJ management Among other popular alternatives to analytics, Hotjar and Smartlook stand out for offering more in-depth insights through various data-gathering approaches (Filip & egan, 2019). By observing real-life customer interaction with digital properties, one can figure out patterns representing a larger population, and thus gain better insights into needed solutions. Customer feedback through page surveys and widgets is also a valuable source of data for CJ mapping, seeding the map with customer thoughts and feelings.

Enabling the Consumer Journey
Digital technologies have significantly changed the way customers engage with brands and effectively make a consumption decision. CJs that do not have at least a few digital-influenced touchpoints are rare, and there always seems to be room available for more digitization. It might be a digital asset that provides information to consumers around their needs or that enables a transaction itself, such as institutional websites or ecommerce. It could be devices from which the customer identifies a particular store location or compares alternatives, a remarketing advertisement through a social network to remind the consumer to come back to the CJ, or even adapting a provided service to better match customer needs. Research has revealed that technology enables touchpoints in four main areas: creating digital touchpoints themselves, giving access to touchpoints, pushing the consumers toward the CJ, and personalizing the consumer experience.

Create touchpoints
Organizational digital properties are technology-enabled usually offered as a service (SaaS). Ramshaw (2016) performed a complete review of CJ mapping software, which evaluated 12 different digital tools to create maps. He suggested that enterprises should use a tool to do the initial mapping and manage its process improvement, which would be achieved by software such as UX360, Visual Paradigm, and SuiteCX. For small and mid-sized companies that cannot afford or do not need the power of such corporate solutions, a reasonable basic option could start with Microsoft PowerPoint or Microsoft Visio. Once the company gets some practical experience and needs to use CJ mapping as a living document, they can migrate to Smaply or Touchpoint Dashboard. Smaply has also proven to be valuable in teaching CJ as a marketing subject, thus bringing potential for more familiarity among marketing professionals (Micheaux & Bosio, 2019).
Even though identifying touchpoints could be an empirical activity, collecting data on such matters is highly recommended. One of the most popular software to analyze CJ data is Google Analytics, which is useful for exploring consumer behaviour based on digital properties with a simplified view. Dimensions that can be extracted through Google Analytics that help the composition of CJ mapping include the behaviour flow of customer clusters, the customer life cycle, and individual data model view (Google, 2018). Identifying the different flows that a population of users with a particular digital property go through might help to lighten the pain points throughout the journey. Moreover, life cycle analysis offers a promising direction about how long a customer takes to move forward with each touchpoint. Taking the viewpoint of an individual customer allows understanding an outlier's behaviour in the journey. Although valuable, Google Analytics might

Figure 2. Drivers for technology usage in Customer Journey
touchpoints where customers can perform one or more stages of the CJ. The most basic application starts with non-transactional websites, which have a strategic role in informing consumers about a product or service, along with raising awareness about a specific need. Firms can use content websites with a branded or unbranded approach, which often serves as a starting point to the journey when aligned with inbound communication and Search Engine Optimization strategies (Ehrlich et al., 2017). The next level of technology-enabled touchpoints includes transactional behaviour, which enables conversions to happen with reduced friction in an omnichannel environment. This can consist of a retail e-commerce platform or a B2B web ordering application.
Mobile apps and responsive websites might play both instructional and transactional roles. Customers that interact with branded mobile applications during the consumption process increase their engagement throughout the journey, spending more on such brands than on non-engaged ones (Wang, 2020). The most common purpose of mobile apps in a CJ context is to support Customer Relationship Management (CRM) practices, activate promotions, and leverage customer loyalty. In addition to explicit mobile touchpoint opportunities, consumers also face implicit touchpoints daily that might influence the CJ, such as reading news or accessing social media, which can be impacted by sponsored content (Wozniak et al., 2018).
Digitizing the in-store experience is also a trend in retail, with the growing adoption of technologies such as complimentary Wifi, interactive screens, virtual mirrors for fitting, self-service kiosks, and QRCode interactions, among others (Mosquera et al., 2017).

Providing access to digital touchpoints
Organizations perceive a given digital property as a single touchpoint, while at the customer level, it might be experienced with variety depending on the device the customer uses to interact with them. These devices are referred to as e-channels, which include computers, mobile devices, Smart TVs, Smart Glasses, Smart Watches, and other new devices that now emerging (Wagner et al., 2020). Wearable technology opens up a new alley of possibilities within the CJ, for example, with self-tracking incentives explored by insurance companies (Paluch & Tuzovic, 2019).
Push the consumer toward the journey One of the most fundamental roles technology plays in CJs is to help customers move through their journey, accomplishing the consumption process in a trustable yet dynamic way. The journey is not the same for every customer, but instead, each one has different timings and needs (De Keyser et al., 2020). Technologies such as machine learning and artificial intelligence help segment, target, and position consumers according to data clusters (Campbell et al., 2020). A navigation footprint made by consumers on digital properties can be translated into intentions, serving as a trigger for proper impulses that an organization can push. Data Management Platforms (DMPs) and Operational Marketing Databases (OMDBs) are technology alternatives to control consumer intentions in a digital environment and generate custom audiences for advertisements (Micheaux & Bosio, 2019). For example, suppose a particular customer navigating on the "Store Locator" page of a specific chain. In that case, its digital marketer could define a strategy to display relevant content through social media advertisements related to in-store behaviour.
Consumers often need some level of support during their journey. Organizations can use digital tools to communicate with consumers, such as mobile instant messaging apps, thereby reducing friction generated by traditional communication methods such as email and telephone (Marino & Lo Presti, 2019). Within instant messaging, firms can use chatbots to create 24-hour first-level customer service powered by Natural Language Processing (NLP) technology, which captures user intentions based on unstructured messages (Singh et al., 2020). For creating more customer proximity, social bots can be used by organizations that simulate human behaviour in social networks, thus generating frictionless interactions (Wilson-Nash et al., 2020).

Personalizing the Journey
When a customer feels actively part of the decisionmaking process along the journey, they have greater engagement. Technology is a strong ally in various levels of personalizing the consumer experience, and supporting a sharing economy (Dellaert, 2019). Digital platforms offer product individualization via mass customization, allowing consumers to co-produce, cobuild, co-design, and co-configure (Pallant et al., 2020). In such an approach, the organization and consumer take on the product design, component selection, and assembly, and use the product together.
By focusing on improving sales conversion on ecommerce platforms, eye-tracking technology allows

How Can Firms Effectively Use Technology in Customer Journey Management
William Boscardini Helouani one to understand the customer's point of view and to customize the experience, generating easier-to-use interfaces (Tupikovskaja-Omovie & Tyler, 2020). By performing an ongoing competitor analysis, dynamic pricing algorithms powered by machine learning and artificial intelligence can suggest and automatically set the most appropriate price for products and services while avoiding pricing anomalies (Campbell et al., 2020). For example, the New York bus service's electronic ticketing system controls the origin and destination of the passenger, making proportional charges to the travel duration. All data from this customization are processed via big data, which enables new customizations on the journey by identifying customer clusters that allow optimizing the service as a whole (Graves et al., 2019).

Monitoring the Consumer Journey
The CJ is a rich source of information for organizations seeking to make more data-driven decisions. Large volumes of data captured at different touchpoints can be processed to generate insights into specific pains in the process, including mining unstructured texts from comments and social networks (McColl-Kennedy et al., 2019). Technologies such as machine learning applied to big data allow firms to analyze the current scenario and understand the market and customer dynamics (Campbell et al., 2020).
Firms that manage to leverage data effectively through advanced analytics have a strategic marketing competitive advantage (Dellaert, 2019). An accurate analysis of the CJ must deal with the heterogeneity of journies, thus allowing an interactive view that does not reduce the user's activities to a small set of actions (Kim et al., 2020). From a practical perspective, once a company learns in which stage a particular consumer is on the journey and combines this knowledge with predictive analytics, it makes a very assertive approach.

Conclusion
By answering one of the open questions around CJ that need the contribution of information systems, the present research sought to offer companies a generalist view on how technology can be used in the context of CJs. By identifying that digital tools can play a relevant role during journey mapping, enabling touchpoints, and the overall monitoring of the journey, this research offers a direction for companies seeking to create effective initiatives to improve their CX. Digital tools play a fundamental role in CX, although many businesses have not yet assimilated the most appropriate technologies for this purpose. New opportunities therefore exist for technology firms to create easy-to-use and affordable products for CJ management. In addition to addressing unanswered questions found in the literature, it is also necessary to perform a detailed review at each of the identified stages of technology usage in CJ, thereby deepening the discussion with case studies and a technical approach.

How Can Firms Effectively Use Technology in Customer Journey Management
William Boscardini Helouani